Review: The Lost Girls by Sonia Hartl

Posted April 8, 2022 by Angie in Book Reviews / 0 Comments

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking those links, I will receive a small commission from the sale at no extra cost to you.

Review: The Lost Girls by Sonia HartlThe Lost Girls by Sonia Hartl
Published by Page Street Kids on September 14, 2021
Genres: LGBTQ, Urban Fantasy, Young Adult Fiction
Format: eBook (197 pages)
Source: Library
Purchase: AmazonIndieBound
Add Book: GoodreadsBookhype

Sonia Hartl’s The Lost Girls is laced with dark humor and queer love; it’s John Tucker Must Die with a feminist girl gang of vampires.

When Elton Irving turned Holly Liddell into a vampire in 1987, he promised her eternal love. But thirty-four years later, Elton has left her, her hair will be crimped for the rest of immortality, and the only job she can get as a forever-sixteen-year-old is the midnight shift at Taco Bell.

Holly’s afterlife takes an interesting turn when she meets Rose McKay and Ida Ripley. Having also been turned and discarded by Elton—Rose in 1954, and Ida, his ex-fiancée, in 1921—they want to help her, and ask for her help in return.

Rose and Ida are going to kill Elton before he turns another girl. Though Holly is hurt and angry with Elton for tossing her aside, she’s reluctant to kill her ex, until Holly meets Parker Kerr—the new girl Elton has set his sights on—and feels a quick, and nerve-wracking attraction to her.


Proceed With Caution:

This book contains blood, death, violence, gore, and kidnapping.

The Basics:

The Lost Girls is narrated by Holly. Holly has been a vampire since 1987, and it sucks. Pun intended. She’s sixteen in mind and body for the rest of her undead life, which leaves her options quite limited. Especially when she’s eternally bound to the ex-boyfriend who changed her in the first place. At least until Rose and Ida find her with a plan to kill their maker and take back their afterlives. But first they must stop him from turning his latest teen fling.

My Thoughts:

You can’t describe a book as John Tucker Must Die with vampires and not expect me to read it! I absolutely love this premise of teen girl vampires going after their terrible maker. While The Lost Girls isn’t a masterpiece, it was a ton of fun and satisfied my craving for a silly vampire novel. And isn’t that all we really want anyway?

The vampires in The Lost Girls aren’t pale creatures of the night. In fact, most vampire myths don’t apply to them. Which makes perfect sense, or how else would Elton be able to hang out in high schools to lure young girls to the dark side. There’s a lot of new vampire lore introduced as the girls come up with their plan to eliminate Elton. It’s interesting, but I think needlessly complicated for this simple story.

However, some things about the vampires in The Lost Girls don’t make sense at all. Apparently, Holly was turned at sixteen over thirty years ago, which means her hair is forever crimped. I get this was done for the laughs, but why would becoming undead make her hairstyle permanent? She also mentions a spot on her knee she missed while shaving that is also forever stuck. Um, it’s hair, just shave it off? Again, it was suppose to be funny, but it’s also just bad world-building.

Another thing that nagged at me from the first chapter was Holly complaining about having to work at Taco Bell and not being able to afford anything because she’s forever-sixteen. It’s not like she has an ID that says “Age: 16 Forever” on it. She can lie; she just might look young for her age. Or she can get a fake ID that says she’s 18 or 20 or something. Or…wait, she does mention that she steals IDs from people at the bar in order to get jobs. Umm..those people aren’t 16…Holly’s time on the night shift at Taco Bell was probably also for comedic purposes, but it doesn’t hold up.

Other than those issues, I really enjoyed The Lost Girls. I loved these very different girls coming together for a common purpose. There are several touching, emotional moments scattered throughout as well. Such as Holly and Parker’s homelives, Ida and Rose’s human lives, and even Holly’s old teacher. Yes, the story is predictable, but I didn’t pick it up to be astonished. I just love vampires. I especially love queer vampires, because of course Holly and Elton’s latest girl, Parker, have to fall in love with each other after having fallen in love with the same jerk. The ending is bittersweet, but I know these girls eventually get their happily forever after.

Sharing is caring!

Tags: , , , ,

[convertkit form=2051772]

Leave a Reply